On January 15, a Pakistani bank must pay an instalment of tax on a year whose books it will close on December 31. Its annual return ordinarily falls due the following September. For roughly twenty months, the Treasury has the use of that January payment. If the bank had lent the money to a business, the State could have taxed the profit. If the Treasury had borrowed the money by selling a bill, it would have paid for the privilege. Advance taxation gives the State access to the funds without having to show that financing cost in its budget.[1]

Government is, in economic terms, a 52 per cent shareholder in the marginal taxable profit of a bank subject to the top super-tax rate. From tax year 2027, the corporate rate is 42 per cent and the highest applicable super-tax rate is 10 per cent. The corresponding combined figures for tax years 2025 and 2026 are 54 and 53 per cent. Accounting profit and the two statutory tax bases can differ. But where both charges apply to the same additional Rs100, the Treasury receives Rs52. It therefore has a direct financial interest in the bank’s capacity to earn.[1]

Rule 5 of the Seventh Schedule to the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 requires twelve payments under section 147, due by the fifteenth of each month. Where the bank’s estimate rises, rule 5(1A) requires a June adjustment. Payment discharges part of the eventual tax bill. Its cost to profitability arises from the income the cash could have earned or the expense of replacing it. Consider a bank that parts with Rs10 billion a year early. At a net incremental yield of 10 per cent, it forgoes Rs1 billion in profit. At a marginal tax rate of 52 per cent, that represents Rs480 million for the bank and Rs520 million in potential tax for the Treasury.

An unpublished banking presentation allows that example to be tested against the scale of actual collections. Its figures, attributed to the Pakistan Banks’ Association, cover the sector as a whole. Reported corporate tax payments rose sixfold in five years. Using Treasury-bill yields attributed to the State Bank of Pakistan, the presentation estimates the income banks could have earned had they paid with their returns, and the additional tax on that income.[2]

Calendar year Tax paid¹ Modelled return¹ Tax on return¹
2021 159.0 26.3 10.2
2022 318.0 81.2 39.8
2023 618.0 219.4 107.5
2024 856.0 277.6 149.9
2025 960.0 201.4 106.8
Total 2,911.0 806.0 414.2

¹ Rs billion. Figures and rounded totals as reported in the presentation.[2]

The headline estimate of Rs414.2 billion in additional tax turns on a timing assumption. The presentation allows the entire annual payment to earn a return for 21 months. By the time the December instalment leaves the bank, eleven of those months have already passed. With equal payments on the fifteenth, a January instalment has about twenty-and-a-half months to run until the following September 30, a December instalment nine-and-a-half. The average is fifteen months.

Keeping the presentation’s rates and treating the payments as equal monthly amounts produces an illustrative Rs523.1 billion in gross foregone earnings and Rs268.0 billion in potential tax over five years.[3] Monthly payment records would permit a better estimate. The source table describes the principal as corporate taxes paid, so current-year advances would first have to be separated from arrears and settlements. A bank’s funding costs, actual use of the money and the tax rate in the period when income accrued would determine how much of the estimated gross yield became taxable profit.

Also Read: Pakistan’s Retail Revolution: $1 Billion Export Ambition, 50 Global Brands And The Battle Against An Unequal Market

The distinction matters most when government itself pays the interest. Suppose the Treasury defers collection and issues additional bills that pay banks Rs1 billion. It might collect Rs520 million in tax on that income, yet still pay Rs480 million more than it receives. A finance minister could reasonably defend advance collection on the ground that it saves borrowing costs. Parliament should then be told what those savings are worth and who supplies them. Where the alternative use is a loan to a manufacturer, the borrower pays the interest and may generate taxable income of its own. The five-year figures cannot establish how much would have gone into either use.

Pakistan once recognised this financing service in law. In their Business Recorder series of January 15–17, 2021, Huzaima Bukhari and this writer traced advance income tax to section 18A, inserted in the Income-tax Act, 1922 during the Second World War in 1944.[4] The original arrangement carried a reciprocal obligation. In Simplex Mills Ltd. v P.S. Subramanyam, the Bombay High Court reproduced the earlier wording of section 18A(5), under which government paid simple interest at two per cent per annum over the prescribed period. The court recorded the interest actually allowed on the company’s advance payment.[5]

Pakistan retained the principle under section 53(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 1979. As Part II of the Business Recorder series put it, “6% compensation was compulsory for advance tax paid under section 53”. Part III drew attention to the length of time for which a calendar-year taxpayer’s money could remain with government and to the particular burden of monthly instalments on banks.[6][7]

A contemporary representation by the Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry identified the Finance Bill, 1995 as the measure withdrawing the six per cent allowance. The chamber argued even then that the rate warranted an increase.[8]

The withdrawal deprived taxpayers of a statutory right they had enjoyed while the earlier provision operated. Today an advance can match the final liability to the last rupee, leaving the bank with no refund and the government with months of free use of the money. Sections 170 and 171 govern refunds and additional payment for delay. They offer no general compensation in that ordinary case. Restoring the earlier principle would require Parliament to decide when compensation starts, how it accrues and which published benchmark governs it.[1]

The same bank also acts as an unpaid collector. When it credits profit to a depositor’s account, its staff and systems must identify the applicable withholding treatment, deduct the proper amount, remit it, maintain records, issue the requisite certificate and report the transaction. An error may require correspondence with the depositor and reconciliation with FBR. The bank pays for this work whether the deduction involves a few hundred rupees or several million. Rule 5(2) addresses the bank’s position as a recipient. Its separate obligations when paying others remain commercially significant.[1]

Section 161 exposes the agent to recovery for failure to deduct, collect or pay. Section 182 prescribes penalties for specified defaults and section 205 provides for default surcharge. The distinctions matter. Where the recipient has already paid the relevant tax, section 161(1B) protects against recovery of that principal from the agent upon the statutory showing, although surcharge can remain payable for the intervening period.

Proving payment may itself consume staff time. Even if Rs100 of compliance expenditure is fully deductible at a marginal 52 per cent, the bank still bears Rs48. A deduction gives the agent only a fraction of what it costs to perform the public service.[1]

Article 11(2) of the Constitution prohibits forced labour. It raises a question about how far the State may compel private persons, on pain of financial sanctions, to administer another person’s tax. The constitutional distinction is between surrendering money and furnishing labour. The former principally raises a financing issue. The latter requires close attention to the work actually demanded and the persons required to perform it.[9]

Article 11(4)(b) expressly preserves compulsory service required by law for a public purpose, subject to the safeguard against cruelty or incompatibility with human dignity. Revenue collection plainly serves a public purpose.

An Article 11 challenge would therefore have to identify the specific duty, its legal authority, the individuals whose labour is engaged and the facts taking the burden beyond that exception.

A company’s expenditure alone establishes little about coercion of its employees. A demand exceeding statutory authority, or a penalty imposed without a fair opportunity to answer it, also engages the more immediate protections of lawful treatment and due process under Articles 4 and 10A. Parliament need not await a constitutional judgment before it pays fairly for the work it assigns.[9]

The Finance Division and FBR should put both sides of the arrangement before Parliament. For banks’ own tax, disclose monthly receipts by the tax year to which they belong, identify excess payments and refunds, and estimate the Treasury’s financing benefit. Phase in instalments based on realistic current earnings, with prompt adjustment of excesses and a published compensation rate for qualifying advances.

For third-party collection, measure the cost of the functions transferred to banks, remove duplicative reporting and price a collection allowance against independently verified costs. Reserve the severest sanctions for conduct that warrants them, particularly the deliberate retention of tax already deducted.

A collection target records the day money reaches the Treasury. It tells Parliament nothing about the earnings forgone before filing day or the expense of collecting a depositor’s tax. When government takes up to Rs52 of every additional Rs100 a bank earns, those omissions also obscure its own financial interest.

Publishing the costs and restoring compensation would oblige the government to defend advance taxation on its full fiscal merits.

Notes

  1. FBR, Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, amended to June 30, 2026. Sections 4C, 118, 147, 151, 160–165, 170–171, 182 and 205. First Schedule, Part I, Divisions II and IIB. Seventh Schedule, rules 5, 6 and 7CA.
  2. Advance Tax on Banks, unpublished sector presentation, 2021–2025, slides 2–7. Payment totals and rates as attributed in the presentation.
  3. Author’s calculation. Annual tax paid × (first-year yield × 0.5 + succeeding-year yield × 0.75). Yield pairs in chronological order: 7/11, 11/17, 17/21, 21/12 and 12/10 per cent. Combined tax rates: 39, 49, 49, 54 and 53 per cent. Simple interest, equal mid-month payments and full taxability assumed.
  4. Ikramul Haq and Huzaima Bukhari, “Advance tax, refunds & compensation—I”, Business Recorder, January 15, 2021.
  5. Simplex Mills Ltd. v P.S. Subramanyam, [1958] 34 ITR 711 (Bombay), paragraphs 2–5.
  6. Huzaima Bukhari and Ikramul Haq, “Advance tax, refunds & compensation—II”, Business Recorder, January 16, 2021.
  7. Ikramul Haq and Huzaima Bukhari, “Advance tax, refunds & compensation—III”, Business Recorder, January 17, 2021.
  8. Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry, archived annual report, Banking & Finance Sub-Committee correspondence on section 53. View source
  9. Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, Articles 4, 10A and 11, especially clauses 11(2) and 11(4)(b).
About the author

Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, writer, literary critic, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.