Every few years, when revenue disappoints, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) discovers that the fault lies in its organogram. The latest development, reported in a section of Press on November 15, 2026, reverses the functional integration of sales tax and income tax administration introduced in 2009. A dedicated Member for sales tax and federal excise duty will report to the FBR Chairman. Separate sales tax zones headed by commissioners are planned within each chief commissioner’s jurisdiction, with restructuring reportedly beginning at Large Taxpayer Offices on December 1, 2026. The justification invokes an estimated sales tax gap of Rs. 3.4 trillion, against Rs. 2 trillion for income tax.

Examine the officials’ own evidence, however, and the case for separation begins to unravel. According to the figures reported, around 90 per cent of sales tax collections come from just 15,000 taxpayers. Of approximately 313,000 persons registered in early 2024, only 190,000 filed returns, many declaring no taxable transactions.

The above figures do not establish a failure of integration. They demand an explanation of how the register is maintained, why filing obligations remain unmet and whether nil returns correspond with actual business activity. A nil return is not itself evidence of evasion; failure to distinguish inactivity from concealed activity is an administrative weakness.

More revealing is the reported comparison between manufacturing sectors. In twelve sectors with production monitoring, the revenue gap fell by twelve percentage points of potential collections over two years; in seven sectors without monitoring, it rose by nine. This is not a controlled experiment: the report does not establish identical officers, comparable sectoral conditions or monitoring as the sole cause. It nevertheless raises an obvious question. If better enforcement outcomes were recorded under the existing arrangement, why is separation presented as necessary before effective tools can be extended?

The other justifications point towards neglected management responsibilities. Officers reportedly met combined targets by concentrating on income tax. That calls for tax-specific performance measures, proper allocation of staff and supervision of neglected work. A Karachi proficiency test reportedly found officers weaker in sales tax matters. That demands scrutiny of training, postings and professional development. Neither admission establishes that another hierarchy is the indispensable remedy.

The argument concerning the common Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) system is equally unpersuasive. Officials suggest that shared digital infrastructure weakens the original rationale for integration. It can equally strengthen the practical case for coordinated administration by making a common taxpayer record more accessible.

Shared software, however, cannot prevent separate chains of command from issuing overlapping notices or adopting inconsistent positions. Technology enables coordination; management must ensure it.

Also Read: PIA Privatisation Set To Unlock Another Rs90 Billion In June 2027 As SOE Losses Mount

The two taxes examine connected aspects of the same business. A sale can affect output tax, turnover and business income. Separate field hierarchies risk sending the same business to different commissioners with repeated demands for the same records. Separate tax returns already exist; the additional danger is duplicated scrutiny.

The IMF’s 2010 toolkit on revenue authorities warned that separate VAT and income-tax departments can generate duplication and multiple audits. Specialisation must be assessed alongside its cost to the taxpayer.

Nor can integration simply be declared tried and found wanting. The World Bank’s May 2019 appraisal of Pakistan Raises Revenue identified unsupportive tax policy, wavering government commitment, inadequate initial ICT planning, frequent leadership changes, insufficient training and partial reversal of functional reorganisation among the shortcomings of the earlier Tax Administration Reform Project. These findings do not prove integration flawless. They prevent its troubled implementation from being treated as a clean test demonstrating the superiority of fragmentation.

What no new zone can change by itself is tax policy. An IMF paper published in 2016 recorded an increase in GST exemptions from 0.1 per cent of GDP in 2012 to 0.8 per cent in 2015. These are historical figures, not estimates of today’s exemptions. Their relevance is straightforward: an energetic commissioner cannot collect revenue that the law has forgone. The policy gap and the compliance gap require different remedies.

Nor does appointing a new Member ensure timely refunds or equal treatment of influential taxpayers. Delaying legitimate refunds can improve immediate cash receipts while depriving businesses of working capital. Performance must therefore be measured after accounting for refund obligations, with publication of outstanding claims and their age. Stronger fraud detection and prompt payment of genuine claims should advance together.

As argued in an earlier  analysis, specialist capacity can be strengthened within shared administration. VAT needs experts in invoice chains, input credits and fraud. Specialist risk teams can work with common registration, shared records and coordinated audits. Separate field structures must demonstrate benefits exceeding their transition costs and additional compliance burden. Their creation cannot constitute proof of their necessity.

The honest questions remain: who stays outside effective enforcement, which concessions survive and why, and whether the estimated gap rests on a published, verifiable method. FBR should disclose the estimate’s reference period, assumptions and distinction between legally forgone revenue and unpaid legal liabilities. Without that explanation, Rs. 3.4 trillion risks becoming a slogan in place of a diagnosis.

Reform that leaves unjustified exemptions, delayed refunds, defective incentives and political protection untouched is merely a change of letterhead. Moving files from one room to another is easy. That is precisely why it is so often attempted.


Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position, values or beliefs of The Scoop or its management.

The Scoop firmly believes in freedom of speech, intellectual diversity and the open exchange of ideas. As an independent media platform, we remain committed to providing space for differing perspectives, including those that may challenge or contradict our own views.

Publication does not constitute endorsement. Our commitment to freedom of expression and independent journalism extends beyond opinions with which we agree.

About the author

The writers, lawyers and authors, are Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), and members of the Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellows of the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE).