A payment received on June 30 can help the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) meet its annual target even when the taxpayer will use it to discharge a liability belonging to a later year. The Treasury has received the money.

The error comes when FBR treats the receipt as evidence that it collected more tax attributable to the year just ended. A change in the date of payment can then produce an apparent improvement in performance without bringing a single additional rupee of income into the tax base.

Take fiscal year (FY) 2024–25. The figures published in Minute Mirror put net income tax collection at approximately Rs. 5713 billion and advance tax at Rs.1894 billion. The advance-tax total alone tells us little about overstatement. Many instalments properly discharge liabilities for the year in question. The amount that matters is the portion credited to this year’s performance although the underlying liability belongs to a later year.

Suppose, for illustration, that Rs. 200 billion of the Rs. 5713 billion consisted of such future-year advances. Suppose also that earlier collections attributable to FY 2024–25 had already been credited appropriately, leaving no offsetting amount to bring in. On those assumptions, collection attributable to the year would be approximately Rs. 5513 billion. Early credit would account for Rs. 200 billion, or 3.5 per cent of the published net figure. Rs. 200 billion is an assumption used to show the effect. The published totals do not establish how much FBR actually obtained early.

One further entry makes all the difference. Suppose that Rs.150 billion collected and counted in the preceding year actually belonged to FY2024–25. A consistent account would bring that Rs.150 billion into FY2024–25 while moving the Rs. 200 billion out. The revised total would then be Rs. 5663 billion. The net overstatement would be Rs. 50 billion, less than one per cent of reported collection. Both examples concern the same year and the same hypothetical Rs. 200 billion received early. What changes is the amount the preceding year had already taken credit for.

Also Read: FCC Strikes Down Provincial Infrastructure Cess, Blocks Recoveries And Penalties As Rs350 Billion Dispute Enters New Phase

This is why pressure to secure ever larger advances can flatter a collection record. Each year starts with some of its revenue already counted towards an earlier target. A field formation can make up the difference by collecting more against future liabilities. If it brings forward exactly as much as its predecessor did, the two timing adjustments cancel for that year. If it brings forward more, the excess improves the apparent result. When the practice stops, the shortfall appears in the year of correction, even if taxpayer compliance has held steady.

The banking example recently examined in The Scoop shows how far the payment date can precede final reconciliation. It also illustrates an important distinction. An instalment may fall legally due before the annual return is filed. Its early statutory due date does not by itself show that FBR collected it under pressure or assigned it to the wrong year. To establish either claim, the payment must be matched to the liability it discharged and, where premature collection is alleged, to its lawful due date.

Both the Finance Ministry and Parliament need the cash figure. They also need a figure against which to judge FBR’s annual performance. FBR could supply it with a short reconciliation alongside each June announcement: cash received during the year, less receipts attributable to later years, plus amounts collected earlier against this year’s liabilities. Arrear recoveries should be identified separately. The illustration above holds refunds and all other adjustments constant so that the effect of advance collection alone is visible.

That disclosure would change the incentive in the field. A commissioner who secures a payment in June against a later year’s liability would receive credit for the cash when it arrives and for the tax in the year it belongs to. Until FBR publishes both entries, Parliament can know how much money reached the Treasury by June 30. It cannot tell how much of the year’s reported achievement was borrowed from the next.

Sources

The Scoop, November 18, 2026: Advance Monthly Tax: Stealing Public Funds, Causing Loss To Banking & State

Minute Mirror, June 19, 2026: Bankruptcy of ideas—VIII: The Oppressive (Tax) State, Table 1

About the author

Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, writer, literary critic, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.