ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s public debt profile remains exposed to six distinct categories of economic and fiscal shocks capable of derailing debt sustainability, with a combined macro-fiscal stress scenario threatening to push public and publicly guaranteed debt to 75.2 per cent of GDP by FY2027, according to a Finance Ministry assessment.

Prepared by the ministry’s Economic Adviser’s Wing using FY2024 data and assumptions, the Debt Sustainability Analysis Report FY2025–FY2027 evaluates vulnerabilities across seven individual stress tests—spanning fiscal slippage in the federal primary balance, slower real GDP growth, interest rate spikes, exchange rate depreciation, combined macro-fiscal pressures, and financial-sector contingent liabilities.

Under the ministry’s baseline scenario, Pakistan’s public and publicly guaranteed debt-to-GDP ratio is projected to ease steadily from 70.4 per cent in FY2024 to 68.6 per cent in FY2025, 67.8 per cent in FY2026, and 66.6 per cent by FY2027. However, the report cautions that adverse macroeconomic or fiscal shifts could swiftly reverse this downward path.

Stress-Test Scenarios: Where the Biggest Risks Lie

The sharpest deterioration emerges under a combined macro-fiscal shock—assuming simultaneous setbacks in economic growth, the federal primary balance, interest rates, and the exchange rate. Under this scenario, public debt climbs to 73.5 per cent of GDP in FY2026 and 75.2 per cent in FY2027, breaching the 70 per cent debt sustainability benchmark used for emerging markets.

Stress-Test Scenario Key Assumption FY2027 Debt-to-GDP FY2027 Gross Financing Needs
Baseline Projection Steady growth, primary surplus 66.6% 19.5%
Combined Macro-Fiscal Shock Simultaneous growth, fiscal, rate & FX shocks 75.2% 22.8%
Primary Balance (Historical Deficit) Return to 1.6% of GDP historical deficit 73.1% 22.8%
Contingent Liability Shock One-time 10% of banking assets + weaker growth 72.8% 21.6%
Real GDP Growth Shock Growth falls by 1 std. deviation for 2 years 70.7% 21.1%
Primary Balance (50% Slippage) 50% reduction in planned fiscal adjustment 69.4% 20.9%
Exchange Rate Shock 15% depreciation of the Pakistani rupee 68.2% 20.1%
Interest Rate Shock 300-basis-point rise in nominal interest rates 68.1% —

The second-largest vulnerability stems from fiscal slippage. While halving planned fiscal adjustments would lift debt to 69.4 per cent by FY2027, reverting to Pakistan’s historical average federal primary deficit of 1.6 per cent of GDP would drive debt to 73.1 per cent. Close behind is a financial-sector contingent liability shock—modelling a one-time non-interest expenditure hit equal to 10 per cent of banking-sector assets alongside weaker growth and fiscal erosion—which would push debt to 72.8 per cent of GDP.

Also Read: FBR Mandates AI-Enabled Electronic Production Monitoring For Paper And Synthetic Leather Sectors

Elevated Financing Needs and Debt Stock Composition

Even without external shocks, the report warns that Pakistan’s gross financing needs (GFN) remain structurally elevated, leaving limited fiscal buffer to absorb unexpected downturns. Baseline GFN is projected at 25.4 per cent of GDP in FY2025, moderating to 21.3 per cent in FY2026 and 19.5 per cent in FY2027—every single year exceeding the 15 per cent emerging-market threshold. Under the combined shock, GFN rises to 23.1 per cent in FY2026 and 22.8 per cent in FY2027.

By the end of June 2024, total public and publicly guaranteed debt stood at Rs74.63 trillion—up Rs8.23 trillion, or 12.41 per cent, from Rs66.40 trillion a year earlier:

  • Public Debt vs. Guarantees: Direct public debt rose from Rs62.88 trillion to Rs71.25 trillion, while publicly guaranteed debt edged down from Rs3.52 trillion to Rs3.38 trillion.
  • Domestic vs. External Split: Domestic obligations climbed 20.26 per cent to Rs48.62 trillion (from Rs40.43 trillion), accounting for 65.2 per cent of the total portfolio. External debt remained broadly flat at Rs26.01 trillion (versus Rs25.97 trillion in June 2023), representing the remaining 34.8 per cent.

Floating-Rate Exposure and External Creditor Profile

The Finance Ministry flags heavy interest-rate exposure as a critical vulnerability inside the domestic debt book. As of December 2023, floating-rate instruments accounted for 74.6 per cent of domestic public and publicly guaranteed debt, leaving just 25.4 per cent on fixed rates—meaning policy-rate shifts transmit rapidly into government debt-servicing costs. By maturity, long-term instruments comprised 68.6 per cent of domestic debt, with short-term borrowing at 31.4 per cent.

By contrast, the external debt portfolio carries lower interest-rate volatility, with 65.4 per cent on fixed rates and 34.6 per cent on floating rates, while medium- to long-term obligations represent 81.1 per cent versus 18.9 per cent in short-term debt. Multilateral lenders held 55 per cent of the external debt stock at end-June 2024, followed by bilateral creditors at 29 per cent and Eurobonds at 8 per cent.

Baseline Assumptions and Policy Priorities

The ministry attributes FY2024’s sharp drop in the debt-to-GDP ratio—from 79 per cent to 70.4 per cent—to exchange rate stability, a federal primary surplus, nascent economic recovery, and lower real interest rates. Sustaining that trajectory through FY2027 rests on ambitious baseline projections:

  • Real GDP Growth: Accelerating from 2.4 per cent in FY2024 to 3.6 per cent in FY2025, 4.8 per cent in FY2026, and 5.5 per cent in FY2027.
  • Average Inflation: Moderating from 23.4 per cent in FY2024 to 12 per cent in FY2025, 7.5 per cent in FY2026, and 7 per cent in FY2027.
  • Federal Primary Balance: Maintaining surpluses of 1.02 per cent of GDP in FY2025, 0.4 per cent in FY2026, and 0.5 per cent in FY2027.

To contain borrowing risks, the report prioritises sustained fiscal consolidation, stronger tax revenue mobilisation, disciplined expenditure management, and lengthening domestic debt maturities. It also calls for diversifying funding channels, smoothing repayment profiles, securing concessional external financing, re-entering international capital markets, and attracting non-resident investment into domestic government securities.

About the author

The newsroom team behind The Scoop's independent business, economy, technology, and markets coverage.